Author Archives: Guest Blogger

Judge Raymond Kethledge on Chevron and the Abdication of Article III Power, by Charles J. Cooper and G. Ryan Snyder

by Guest Blogger — Wednesday, June 27, 2018

In our last post, we discussed Judge Kethledge’s longstanding commitment to enforcing the separation of powers. In this post, we will explain how that commitment has shaped his approach to Chevron, which requires judicial deference to agency interpretations of ambiguous statutes. The Constitutional Case Against Chevron Judge Kethledge’s views on Chevron originate with the text […]

This entry was tagged .

The Appearance of Impartiality in Lucia v. SEC , by Kent Barnett

by Guest Blogger — Wednesday, June 27, 2018

In a narrow decision, the Supreme Court held in Lucia v. SEC that the Securities and Exchange Commission’s administrative law judges are “officers of the United States.” Because they are officers, the Constitution’s Appointments Clause required the Commissioners themselves, not others within the agency, to appoint the ALJs. Upon resolving the appointments question, Lucia teed […]

This entry was tagged .

The Future of Chevron Deference: Of Zombie Fungus and Acoustic Separation, by Jeffrey Pojanowski

by Guest Blogger — Thursday, June 21, 2018

The Supreme Court tossed a proverbial squib into the administrative law world this morning, and the takes, hot and otherwise, are sparking everywhere. It handed down three decisions with implications for administrative law: Lucia v. SEC, Pereira v. Sessions, and Wisconsin Central Ltd. v. United States. Lucia, which already had its own symposium on this […]

Judge Raymond Kethledge and the Separation of Powers, by Charles J. Cooper and G. Ryan Snyder

by Guest Blogger — Monday, June 18, 2018

In recent years, several posts on this blog have analyzed how individual judges on President Trump’s Supreme Court shortlist approach questions of administrative law. (See here and here.) To our knowledge, however, no one has written about one of the leading contenders—Judge Raymond Kethledge. This two-part series attempts to fill that gap. The first post […]

This entry was tagged .

Skidmore, Not Auer, Deference for Foreign Governments’ Views of Their Own Law, By Jeffrey Lubbers

by Guest Blogger — Friday, June 15, 2018

In my April 9 guest blogpost, “Auer Deference with a Foreign Twist,” I discussed the issues before the Court in Animal Science Products, Inc. v. Hebei Welcome Pharmaceutical Co. Ltd. The case involved a federal class action antitrust and price-fixing jury trial verdict for $147 million against two Chinese vitamin C manufacturers that was overturned […]

This entry was tagged .

The Colorado Baker Opinion Should Not Be Considered an Administrative Law Precedent, by Richard J. Pierce, Jr.

by Guest Blogger — Thursday, June 7, 2018

Masterpiece Cakeshop v. Civil Rights Commission required the Supreme Court to determine the validity of an order issued by the Colorado Civil Rights Commission that required a baker to bake and sell a wedding cake to a gay couple who were exercising the right to marry that the Court conferred on them in Obergefell v. […]

This entry was tagged .

Finality, Guidance Documents, and San Francisco’s Challenge to a Guidance Repeal, by Alisa Tiwari, Ryan Yeh, and Christine Kwon

by Guest Blogger — Monday, May 21, 2018

San Francisco City Attorney Dennis Herrera filed a lawsuit[i] on April 5, 2018, challenging U.S. Attorney General Jeff Sessions’s repeal of six Department of Justice (DOJ) civil rights guidance documents. The lawsuit argues that Sessions rescinded these civil rights protections for marginalized communities without meaningful explanation, in violation of the Administrative Procedure Act (APA). *** […]

This entry was tagged .

Context-Specific Seminole Rock Reform, by Aneil Kovvali

by Guest Blogger — Monday, May 21, 2018

Applying deference under Bowles v. Seminole Rock, 325 U.S. 410 (1945), courts have deferred to agency interpretations of agency rules for decades. But a recent concern that the doctrine permits agencies to combine the powers of lawmaking and law interpretation has prompted Congress and the courts to consider reform. In a new Essay, forthcoming in […]

This entry was tagged .

Trump v. Hawaii: A Run of the Mill Administrative Law Case, by Kathryn E. Kovacs

by Guest Blogger — Thursday, May 3, 2018

The Supreme Court appears to be poised to uphold the so-called Travel Ban at issue in Trump v. Hawaii. At the oral argument, some of the justices seemed concerned about the Court second-guessing an order that came from the President himself and that concerned national security. Neither of those factors, however, should hinder the Court […]

This entry was tagged .

Accusers as Adjudicators in Agency Enforcement Proceedings, by Andrew N. Vollmer

by Guest Blogger — Tuesday, May 1, 2018

Largely because of the Supreme Court’s 1975 decision in Withrow v. Larkin, the accepted view for decades has been that a federal administrative agency does not violate the Due Process Clause by combining the functions of investigating, charging, and then resolving allegations that a person violated the law. Many federal agencies have this structure, such […]

This entry was tagged .