As Will Baude reminds us, courts often do important things that don’t receive enough attention. Baude dubbed this dynamic the “shadow docket” in the context of the Supreme Court, but there is no reason why his insight is limited to the Justices. Courts everywhere make decisions that are significant but yet don’t end up in […]
Justice Kennedy’s opinion for the majority in Encino Motorcars, LLC v. Navarro is significant for a number of reasons. For one, it marks the first time that the Supreme Court has used a Perma.cc link in an opinion—a victory for the Harvard Law School Library and its Perma.cc partners in their fight against link rot […]
There has been much excitement on the playground of administrative law about the recent decision in Encino Motorcars LLC v. Navarro, in which the Court refused to defer to a Labor Department regulation under the Fair Labor Standards Act. Perhaps because of swirling background debates over Chevron, arbitrariness review, “libertarian administrative law,” and the robustness […]
Thanks to Chris Walker for inviting me to join the conversation about last week’s net neutrality decision. Previous posts by Aaron Nielson and Daniel Deacon did an excellent job highlighting one of the decision’s major themes, the dialogue between the majority and the partial dissent regarding the proper amount of scrutiny to apply to arbitrary […]
The administrative law professoriate is abuzz about the Supreme Court’s recent opinion in Encino Motorcars, LLC v. Naravrro . The 6-2 majority vacated and remanded the 9th Circuit’s rejection of a challenge to a Department of Labor regulation that would have entitled certain car dealership employees to overtime pay. Legal academics and administrative lawyers presently […]
Today the Supreme Court decided Cuozzo Speed Technologies v. Lee, a case concerning the scope of inter partes review by the Patent Trial and Appeal Board—a review procedure created by the Leahy-Smith America Invents Act of 2012 (AIA). The Court ruled in favor of the Patent and Trademark Office (PTO) on two separate issues: (1) that […]
I wanted to follow up on Aaron Nielson’s great post about the D.C. Circuit’s long-awaited net neutrality opinion with a couple of related thoughts. (I saw, as I was writing this post, that Professor Daniel Lyons also has a post up on the Volokh Conspiracy touching on similar points.) For one, it’s interesting how Judge […]
Yesterday, the Supreme Court decided a False Claims Act suit that has enormous implications for Medicare and Medicaid fraud. The allegations in Universal Health Services v. United States ex rel. Escobar are startling. Yarushka Rivera, a young Medicaid beneficiary, died of an adverse reaction to medication that she’d received to treat her bipolar disorder. After […]
My son is away at camp this week, and that’s probably for the best. It means he has missed the last two NBA Finals games. One of his least favorite players is LeBron James, and LeBron—by any measure—has had a pretty amazing week. At the same time, my son is a huge fan of Shaun […]
Yesterday, the D.C. Circuit announced its decision in United States Telecom Association v. FCC, i.e., the Net Neutrality case.* The co-authored majority opinion (Judges Tatel and Srinivasan) upheld the FCC’s new scheme over Judge Williams’ partial dissent. Reviewing the competing opinions, I was struck by something: the asymmetrical treatment of economists. First, let’s review the […]
If you’re one of the six people left who still hasn’t had enough of ACA litigation, you’re in luck. Yesterday, a health plan in Maryland sued the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, arguing that it has botched the implementation of the risk adjustment program. The risk adjustment program is one of the three R’s—reinsurance, […]
Over at Jotwell, Linda Jellum reviews The Principle of Legality and a Common Law Bill of Rights – Clear Statement Rules Head Down Under by Daniel Meagher.* Here’s a summary of the paper from the SSRN abstract (the paper is available on SSRN here): This article traces the evolution in Australia of fundamental rights protection […]
Yesterday, while scanning my Twitter feed, I found myself reading a great article in The Atlantic: “The Senate Finally Passed Chemical Safety Reform.” This article is well worth your time, especially because the legislation is now headed to President Obama for his signature. As I was reading, however, I noticed something: two uses of the […]
By my count, health plans have filed five separate lawsuits in the Court of Federal Claims seeking money that they’re owed under the risk corridor program. As I’ve explained here and here, I think the lawsuits have merit, which is why I expect to see a lot more of them. If you’re a health plan, […]
As I mentioned in my AdLaw Bridge series post last week, I’m slowly catching up* on highlighting the Jotwell Administrative Law Section reviews from the last couple months as part of this series. Here is another terrific Jotwell review, this one by Mark Seidenfeld of Political Parties and Presidential Oversight by Michael Livermore, which was […]